Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label advertising

I Suck, Therefore I Advertise.

Hospital marketers (and the CEOs who demand so little of them) try to advertise services they believe are distinctive.  They have no trouble finding an agency to spend their money, though they're frequently wrong about the 'distinctive' part. Here's an article making the reverse case: bloated advertising budgets are a symptom of undistinguished, undifferentiated services.  Call it a tax on mediocrity.  Says the article, "You will, in effect, be taxed in media dollars for what you failed to spend in research and development."  And "Advertising is the tax you pay for a bad idea." (a quote attributed to Robert Stephens, founder, Geek Squad) "Here's a startling fact: For what equals a rounding error in most big-brand ad budgets, companies could create meaningful new product(s) that would eliminate much of the required ad budget , thus saving themselves—while also earning—millions and millions of dollars." Great products and services...

Marketing's Old Guard...

...in a rear-guard action?  From ClickZ : "Sure, the old guard (in advertising) may talk the talk, but the numbers seem to say that they don't know what they're talking about. A recent study by Alterian found that seven out of 10 marketing professionals admit to having little or no understanding about how their brand (or their clients' brand) is being discussed in social media. Let me say that again: 70 percent of people who do marketing for a living have no knowledge of what's going on with their brands in the social media space!" I haven't read Alterian's study in great detail, but neither do I have evidence that a 70 percent clueless estimate is too high, especially in health care. Is it that they don't know, or don't want to know?   The old guard grew up believing that they were the conversation or, at the very least, were firmly in control.  They talked.  We listened, awestruck. On some level, they probably knew that conversations...

Advertising: The Best (Or Worst) Of Times

 Does advertising have a future? Mad Men or just mad?   From Bloomberg Business Week : "We're not dead yet!" say the "lumbering advertising behemoths." Boot Camp for digital immigrants.   From Fast Company : A moment of unsettling disruption filled with possibilities.  "There's never been a better time to be in advertising...or a worse time."

Drake University Gets A D+

These days it's easy to generate buzz.  Just do something stupid. Drake University in Des Moines, IA set out to re-brand itself.  The result is over there to the left.  Apparently some faculty, students and alumni (read: donors) aren't impressed.  I don't blame them. Drake officials refer to the campaign as "intentionally edgy" and seem quite sure that those who are "Drake material" will understand.  Lest you think those of us NOT living in central Iowa are insufficiently edgy, we, too, get it.  Drake's name begins with a 'D' and adding the '+' sign is subtle and cool because Drake is a university with aspirations...what's not to get? Maybe we're better at ignoring the "even bad publicity is better than none at all" crowd.   Had this controversy not erupted, it's entirely probable that Drake's name would never have appeared in this modest little blog.  So should we say 'mission accomplished?...

"20 Out Of 20 Really Crappy Companies Use Oracle Software!"

Sign seen as I hurried through an airport last week.  A sign so startling I jumped over a barrier and off the moving sidewalk to take a photo. So the Top 20 Airlines (now THERE'S a club from which I'd be happily blackballed...) use Oracle software.  Great.  Now I have someone to blame. "They all use our software and they all suck, more or less."  Woo-Hoo!  I'm all over that!  I'm gonna get me some Oracle! I suspect the message is technically true, as it offers "Better Results..." not "World-Beating, Customer-Pleasing Results..." Still, is this something you'd flaunt, especially when your customers are not highly regarded by THEIR customers?

Dumb Clients? Clueless Agencies? Pick One...Or Both.

The mind reels and the eyes spin after a 1,000 mile cross-country drive.  Why? Not for the traffic jams caused by Illinois' mind-numbingly stupid decision to waste "stimulus" dollars repaving an already perfectly-smooth I-55 from St. Louis to Joliet.  You expect idiocy from Illinois politicians.  And the paving contractor is probably some pol's brother-in-law. No, my allergic reaction stems more from the astounding numbers of bad, really, truly, horribly, miserably, wretched billboards devoted to hospital marketing messages.  C'mon people.  What are you THINKING? Dumb clients?  Clueless agencies?  One has to wonder. Copy that rambles on...and on...and on.   Can't ANYBODY get to the POINT in 6 words or less? Colors that wash out in the sun...and under sodium vapor lights...and at dawn...and dusk.  Isn't someone paying for these things DRIVING THE BOARD once in a while? Acronyms and buzzwords. Do you REALLY think a billboard is...

Ditching 'Chevy' Puts 'Chevrolet' In the Ditch

From The New York Times:  A new ad agency got involved and now memos are flying asking that employees call it 'Chevrolet' not 'Chevy.'  "...though the (latter) is one of the world’s best-known, longest-lived product nicknames." “We’d ask that whether you’re talking to a dealer, reviewing dealer advertising, or speaking with friends and family, that you communicate our brand as Chevrolet moving forward,” said the memo, which was signed by Alan Batey, vice president for Chevrolet sales and service, and Jim Campbell, the G.M. division’s vice president for marketing. “When you look at the most recognized brands throughout the world, such as Coke (sic) or Apple for instance, one of the things they all focus on is the consistency of their branding,” the memo said. “Why is this consistency so important? The more consistent a brand becomes, the more prominent and recognizable it is with the consumer.” Batey and Campbell are right about employees acting as brand am...

Straight-Talk Marketing Pays Off For Domino's

Domino's tosses barbs at itself, and it is paying off - chicagotribune.com "You can't do candor all the time, but once or twice, it works." states Mac Brand, a consultant in Chicago for Bellwether Food Group Inc. My question: why can't you do candor all the time? And why shouldn't you?  Concluding otherwise implies a level of confidence in fooling a great many of your customers at least some of the time. How many leading brands are built and sustained on THAT foundation? Your customers are usually the first to find out about your lousy quality, not the last. So just whom are you kidding by not "doing candor all the time?"

Are We All Managed Care Freudians Now?

Nearly two decades ago, when I saw that Aetna billboard on I-294 near Chicago reading "Health care for the rest of your life" I feared physicians and hospitals were on the verge of losing control over their destiny and their industry. Why the fear?  Notice Aetna's wording:  it's "HEALTH CARE for the rest of your life" not "INSURANCE for the rest of your life." Not "MANAGED CARE..."  And it's it's darn sure not "MEDICAL LOSS RATIOS AND RECISSIONS..." Undoubtedly many saw it as just another billboard, another ad campaign.  Big deal.  Indelicate, possibly inaccurate wording, but ultimately harmless, right?  After all how much can agency creative types know about health care?  Except it came true.  Physicians and hospitals DID lose control and show few signs of getting it back. Though I've never considered myself a Freudian, I am starting to reconsider his belief that many things appearing accidental really aren...

"Take Me Out To the (Ad Message Here) Ball Game!"

The Wall Street Journal reviews stadium naming deals and finds little point in raging against the practice, but even scanter evidence that brand sponsors always get what they're paying for. "A study in a 2002 edition of the Journal of Advertising Research showed that naming-rights deals do help the companies—at least in the short term. The stock prices of 49 companies studied rose an average 1.7% the day they announced such agreements. "But a 2003 paper in the Journal of Sports Economics that tracked the stocks of 54 companies for 20 days after the signings showed that only two showed a statistically significant difference—and in both cases, the stock price fell. "Naming rights is about one thing: boys with toys," says the study's co-author, Michael Leeds, an economics professor at Temple University." Health care boys (and girls) like toys, too. There's Parkview Field in Ft. Wayne, IN , a $3 million deal over ten years. The Methodist Hospital Sys...

The Bigger They Are...

Interesting juxtaposition of marketing impressions during today's travels. First, a billboard from a large health system (full disclosure: a prior place of employment) advertising robotic surgery. I formed several opinions during the 1.64 seconds the billboard was in view. From least-worst to most: Questionable : a marketing tactic based on the theory (if the word 'theory' isn't granting too much credit) that motorists speeding down one of Chicago's busiest expressways really care about having their prostate reamed robotically. Personally, I'm not persuaded. Worse : the billboard's profusion of words, typefaces, fonts, logos and images. So many as to be confusing and, ultimately, ineffective. Utterly wretched : the copy's light yellow colors on a white background. Hard to read in the daylight and nearly invisible under sodium vapor lights at night. Who does yellow on white billboards anyway? All in all, a nice way to waste $100k plus the agency...

Minimally Invasive Prostate Surgery: Not Always Better

Today's NY Times reports on a JAMA article comparing outcomes from various types of prostate surgeries . The study found that increasingly-popular minimally invasive techniques have more of the complications men worry most about: impotence and incontinence. “People intuitively think that a minimally invasive approach has fewer complications, even in the absence of data,” said Dr. Jim C. Hu, the study’s lead author, who is director of urologic robotic and minimally invasive surgery at Brigham and Women’s Hospital in Boston. “Men who were well educated and had higher incomes were actually more likely to embrace this approach, often due to aggressive marketing by hospitals that had spent $1.5 million to acquire the robots . I think the technology has been oversold.” ... Dr. Peter Scardino, chief of surgery at Memorial Sloan-Kettering, said the study was important because it reported on data that did not come just from one medical center or one region. “At the end of the day,” Dr. Sca...

The Illusion Of Control

Advertising gives you the illusion that you control the conversation. You're talking. Surely "they" are listening. And of course "they" are paying attention and dutifully acting as you wish. Insight occurs when realization dawns: Most people live their lives happily ignoring you. Of those devoting part of their limited attention span to your message, most neither care very much nor remember very long. The select few who BOTH care AND remember apply their OWN interpretive filters which may (though usually not) match your own. So give up the illusion that you're in control of the conversation. You aren't. You never were. Let the learning begin.

Now That I Have Your Attention...

What The F**K is Social Media? View more presentations from Marta Kagan . (Thanks to Chris Spagnuolo’s EdgeHopper for the heads-up.) The Takeaway: Markets are conversations. Consumers trust each other more than they trust you or your ads. And they're talking about you right now, whether you know it or not. So participate. Get involved. Engage. Join the conversation.

We Finished In Last Place So...

...after firing everyone responsible, we're designing a new logo. Yep, that'll work. THE TAKEAWAY: Whatever your organization's problems, they weren't caused by your logo. Whatever the solutions, a new logo is usually an expensive, unnecessary distraction. Are you going to drink more Pepsi or Pepsi products now that the logo has morphed into some weird emoticon? Were I Pepsi's marketing guru, I would have found a way to distribute Gatorade Endurance Formula to stores, well, ANYWHERE, thus pleasing us triathletes who think their current eye-dropper-like distribution strategy is resoundingly idiotic. And raise your hand if you think the Detroit Lions' new logo will pull them out of last place. Or make their fans forget 2008. Oh, I know, it's part of the revival of a great brand, bringin g new passion and energy...blah blah. Heck, I call myself a "brand-builder" and even I don't believe that stuff. Brands are not logos and symbols, they...

"Groundhog Day" In Health Care

THE TAKEAWAY: Don't try to create strategic separation by informing your marketplace that you’re JUST NOW offering something that’s been commonplace for decades in the rest of the world. So...I was driving to Chicago’s O’Hare Airport yesterday evening, when I hear a radio ad for a local hospital, one I competed with for two decades (at least when we weren’t doing joint ventures together. But I digress...) Said ad spent 60 breezy, breathless seconds praising the facility’s “new” wireless IT infrastructure. Wow! Think about it! Wireless ANYWHERE! So visitors can GET ONLINE! And doctors and nurses can COMMUNICATE WIRELESSLY! A fairly expensive campaign, I’m assuming, given Chicago’s media costs and the drive time placement on the biggest, baddest station of ‘em all. And a great campaign...for 1995. And for the exactly three people on the planet who’ve never been to Starbuck’s. Maybe the campaign’s next ad will tell me all about how they’re connected to the electrical power gr...

The Will To Power...In Marketing

Great article from strategy+business: "Measuring Your Way To Market Insight." Authors Leslie H. Moeller and Edward C. Landry show you the path to analytical prowess - about your customers, your marketing and your ROI... "As marketers move to a more varied, shifting mix of advertising and promotion, they are coming face to face with the lack of insight they have historically had about which media choices work well, why customers buy, and what returns will be generated by their spending. This lack of insight did not matter very much when marketers had no choice but to depend on television, radio, and print — the traditional mass-market media. Television’s gross ratings points (GRPs), which measure the percentage of a target audience reached by a particular advertisement, didn’t explain why particular ads or placements led to increased sales and others didn’t, but that combination of mass media and metrics was the only game in town. Now, however, there has been an explosio...