Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label strategy

Does Your Strategy Account For the Future?

"Your rearview mirror is so small and your windshield is so large because what lies ahead is much more important than the past." (@CHRISVOSS) What can we say about the future?  It's uncertain and the end is always near. (Jim Morrison)  The future is much like the present, only longer.  (Dan Quisenberry)  The future is here.  It's just not widely distributed yet. (William Gibson)  Uncertain. As near as tomorrow. Long duration.  Limited (and uneven) distribution. Think about how hospital strategic plans account for future competitor decisions.   If they do at all,  it's little more than simple extrapolation of past performance, a technique which, though understandable since that's where the data reside, is nothing more than crafting strategy in a vacuum. It's much easier to track competitor performance retrospectively than to forecast future decisions. Volume trends, market share, patient satisfaction, quality indicators, financia...

Most Hospital M&A Transactions Are Financially Unsuccessful

From Healthcarefinancenews.com:  "Most hospital M&A transactions are financially unsuccessful, study says." "According to a recent study, a majority of hospital and health system merger and acquisition transactions have not been financially successful. "Booz & Company, a global management consulting firm, analyzed a sample of 220 hospitals with pre- and post-transaction performance data over a 10-year period (between 1998 and 2008) and found that less than half (41 percent) of all acquired hospitals outperformed their market. [...] "Sanjay suggested that it’s important for hospitals to merge with other hospitals that have like-minded views about the future and culture, as well as shared views around their positioning in the market. "So, for example, a merger between an academic medical center and a small, community hospital in an underserved area may not be ideal."

NFP Hospitals Hit the Wall

Have nonprofit healthcare providers' improvement efforts hit a wall?  Standard & Poor's Rating Services seems to think so, in this story (via Reuters.)   From the story: "Adding to pressures, inpatient volumes are dropping. "With pending budget sequestration at the federal level, health reform implementation, and continuing pressure on state budgets, we believe the next several years will be difficult for most providers," said S&P. "Furthermore, we believe that the improvements of the past several years may be reaching their limit and thus will not be able to keep pace with longer-term revenue pressures, especially in light of weaker volumes." "S&P says more rating downgrades are possible for not-for-profit healthcare systems over the next two years. It noted that the proportion of systems with positive or stable outlooks is shrinking, which "supports our opinion the multiyear trend of improved financial ratios is unlikely to...

What Does Culture Eat For Breakfast?

Photo by: Cillian Storm Creative Commons Not strategy.  Leaders, more likely, at least those managing by catchphrase, as Dan Beckham suggests . From the article: "The Problem of Buying into the Catchphrase "One proponent of the "culture eats strategy" catchphrase, Shawn Parr, an innovation and design consultancy CEO, made his case in a Jan. 24, 2012, Fast Company article holding out shoe company Zappos as an example. In response, Bob Frisch, a strategy expert with experience at the Boston Consulting Group, had this to say in the same publication a month later: "Parr attributes the success of Zappos to a culture that is inclusionary, encouraging, and empowering.' Customer service representatives write zany emails and company leaders have often affirmed their belief that if you get culture right, success follows. But Zappos also has fast delivery, deep inventory, a 365-day return policy and free shipping both ways. That's a strategy — not a...

Healthcare CEO's Guide to Avoiding the Newspaper Industry's Mistakes

Imagine an industry, slow-moving, comfortable and secure in assuming its own irreplaceability.  Health care?  Well, yes,  But also newspapers, and therein lies a lesson or two. From Forbes here's the Healthcare CEO's Guide to Avoiding Newspaper Industry Mistakes : (note that the underlined emphases are mine.) "Health system CEOs would be well advised to study what newspaper industry leaders did (or perhaps more appropriately, didn’t do) when faced with a dramatic industry change. Turn back the clock 15 years and the following dynamics were present: Newspaper leaders knew full well that dramatic change was underway and even made some tactical investments. However they didn’t fundamentally rethink their model. Newspapers were comfortable as monopoly or oligopoly businesses allowing for plodding decisions. Their IT infrastructure mirrored the plodding pace with expensive and rigid technology architectures. Newspaper companies bought up other ...

5 Reasons Your Healthcare Integration Strategy Is Going To Fail

From Eliot Muir, iNTERFACEWARE , Special to ZDNet: " I hate being the bearer of bad news, but I can tell you, with 100 percent certainty, that your integration strategy is going to fail. That’s the good news. The bad news is that when your strategy fails, there will be a start-up with only a handful of employees and even less money waiting in the wings to take over your market share. I am not trying to paint a gloomy picture; I am just sharing hardcore facts upfront. ... " ...healthcare organizations looking to inoculate themselves from integration failure should follow a few common-sense, tried and true rules: develop a clear strategy up front, keep current with technology, leverage the cloud, be flexible about standards and always look at the opportunity costs inherent in custom development." [Read more...]

"I've Cracked It!"

Reportedly Steve Jobs' final words about Apple's long-rumored venture into the thickets of TV programming.  So has Apple, indeed, "cracked it?"  Let's hope so. Analyst Shaw Wu on why Apple should enter the TV business: “What’s missing is live broadcast television,” he wrote. “One obvious way to offer this is via the traditional way where a user subscribes to cable or satellite. But a more revolutionary, disruptive and differentiated way, is via the internet or IPTV which would be more in-line with its iTunes and iCloud model. Because of the high dependence on content providers, we believe exact timing is difficult to pinpoint.” He added, “We continue to hear what AAPL would love to do is offer users the ability to choose their own customized programming, i.e., whichever channels/shows they want for a monthly subscription fee. This is obviously much more complicated from a licensing standpoint. And in our view, would change the game for television and g...

Wal-Mart Wants To Be Your Doctor

And your manager of chronic diseases. And your pharmacist. And maybe your health coach. They could even play in your ACO sandbox. In response to the article, Wal-Mart says they’re NOT, repeat NOT “… building a national, integrated low-cost primary health care platform..." OK, got it.  Not. Unless, of course, they are. It’s hard to deny their interest when a few scant weeks ago the retailer sent out a request for partners to help it "dramatically ... lower the cost of healthcare ... by becoming the largest provider of primary healthcare services in the nation." It's no surprise that hospitals and physicians face stiff competition from unexpected directions.  These deep-pocketed newcomers care not a fig for our outdated business models, our glacial decision-making and our ability to pervert most innovations that might disrupt the status quo. [Read more from NPR blogs...]

"It is so simple, just do what you love."

Christina Stevens writes about senior living at her blog "Next Wave." Good stuff.

"Major segments of the US economy have been lost, in some cases, forever."

From Clayton Christensen being interviewed by Steve Denning for Forbes : "Firms need to be evaluating future investments strategically in terms of how they will affect their capacity to go on delighting their customers for a sustained period in the future. "For managers trained in traditional business school thinking, the idea that pursuit of profit is the problem, rather than the solution to the economy’s problems, may come as a shock. For business school professors who have spent their lives teaching the focus on profits and the use of IRR and RONA to measure profits, the coming change may be even more disturbing. "Like all new ideas, in the first instance it will be rejected. Then it will be ridiculed. Finally it will be self-evident and no one will be able to remember why anyone ever thought otherwise."

Knock Knock! Anybody Home In Strategic Planning?

From Georgia Everse at HBR Blog Network:  "Eight Ways to Communicate Your Strategy More Effectively." Great ideas for those of you wondering why your strategy, lovingly crafted and lavishly announced, with great effort and more than a little expense, landed in your organization with a hollow thud...followed by deafening silence. [Read more...]

McKinsey: Testing Your Strategy

From McKinsey Quarterly: Ten timeless tests can help you kick the tires on your strategy, and kick up the level of strategic dialogue throughout your company.   Before you tell me you're tired of test-taking, results show that most companies' strategies pass fewer than four of the ten tests. Test #1 is Will your strategy beat the market? "All companies operate in markets surrounded by customers, suppliers, competitors, substitutes, and potential entrants, all seeking to advance their own positions...The best companies are emulated by those in the middle of the pack, and the worst exit or undergo significant reform. As each player responds to and learns from the actions of others, best practice becomes commonplace rather than a market-beating strategy. Good strategies emphasize difference—versus your direct competitors, versus potential substitutes, and versus potential entrants." Key to McKinsey's analysis is this: markets drive a reversion to mean performan...

Which Economies Matters More? Scale or Connection?

Dan Beckham offers his perceptive and timely insights into why "economies of connection" matter more than the CEO and investment banker-beloved "economies of scale." "As health care leaders consider the future, they would be wise to abandon notions of "economies of scale" rooted in financial transactions and mass production. It's time to pursue those mergers and acquisitions that provide the best opportunities to consolidate caregivers in a way that facilitates "economies of connection." Whoever gets there first may be able to lock in a long-lasting advantage." (emphasis mine) [Read more...]

MN Hospital System Partners With Chicago Incubator

From MedCity News:  Ridgeview Medical Center, a health network comprising an acute care hospital and seven clinics in the far western suburbs of Minneapolis, announced that it is partnering with Healthbox , which will launch a three-month acceleration program for healthcare tech entrepreneurs in January. “Our philosophy has changed over the past couple of years in that we want to be involved in healthcare innovation and in the development of disruptive technologies,” said Robert Stevens, president and CEO of Ridgeview Medical Center. “We want to create change within the industry as opposed to complain about what’s happening to healthcare by changes coming from the outside.” [Read more...]

News From the ACO Frontier

Tennesee's Saint Thomas Health is projecting a January launch for MissionPoint Health Partners, an ACO-qualified organization but one with bigger aspirations and a smart partnering strategy. From The Tennessean: "The partners include Saint Thomas Health’s five hospitals and 200 affiliated physicians, Cisco Systems, The Advisory Board Co.’s Crimson Services initiative, Applied Health Analytics and the YMCA of Middle Tennessee. " MissonPoint is using a telemedicine platform from computer networking giant Cisco to improve access to medical specialists for rural, underserved communities. It plans to expand use of the high-definition video system to two other Middle Tennessee communities and add new specialties such as dermatology and psychiatry. "Nashville-based Applied Health Analytics’ part of the mission is to help pinpoint health risks within populations of employees and recommend ways to address those problems, which could include a high rate of obesity, for e...

The Blade Runner Strategy

Though I consider myself a planner and a strategist, I only reluctantly admit to engaging in debates about terms like "mission" and "vision." What are they? How are they defined? Which is which? Honestly, I long ago stopped caring. Instead, I prefer the term "legacy" - i.e. a gift, a bequest, something handed down to future generations. Think about it this way: imagine someone - an historian - sitting down in 50 years to write YOUR history and your organization's. What are you creating TODAY that's worth memorializing? What are you doing TODAY that might, possibly, endure for longer than a strategic planning cycle or two? What's your gift? More about that in a moment... Last night I watched a 3 hour-long meta-movie - a movie about a movie - about the making of the movie Blade Runner, Ridley Scott's dystopic, claustrophobic vision of the not-so-distant future. Blade Runner was released in 1982, the same summer as E.T., early in the d...

How Close To Insanity Is Healthcare Strategy?

“Strategic insanity is doing the same things as everybody else and expecting better results.” (A paraphrase of Albert Einstein.) A recent Harvard Business Review article talked about overcoming hidden cognitive limitations.  “Strategic leaders must be practitioner psychologists who expertly analyze and manage their own and others’ thought processes…identifying successful strategies that are different, unique and distant from the status quo.” Amen.  But not always a comfortable place to be is it?  Telling your organization that thought processes need to change, that they're outdated and predictable.   That the status quo should be avoided because of its limitations, not prized for its stability. So the job of a strategist is to reframe thought processes and mental models.    Let's do a deep dive into the weeds of health care thinking and modeling to see what shakes out.   And let's assume that you, dear reader, are serious about creatin...

Wellpoint Buys CareMore Health Group and Why You Should Care

LA Times : "Cerritos healthcare provider CareMore Health Group is being acquired by health insurance giant WellPoint Inc. for about $800 million as part of an effort to bolster the insurer's profile in senior care as baby boomers age." Like with the Humana-Concentra deal, insurers have a vision for value-driven health care that's quite different from most hospitals' 'let's avoid it until Medicare sweetens the pot' posture. "The deal, announced Wednesday, will give WellPoint a boost as it competes for a piece of the fast-growing elderly care market, said Ana Gupte, an analyst with New York research firm Sanford C. Bernstein. "They've purchased a company that has a strong record of managing chronic disease and clinics that specialize in caring for seniors," Gupte said." Hospitals are in full-blown dither mode about ACOs.  Should we or shouldn't we?  Now? Next year? Never?  Ever?  Some caution is probably appropriate at t...

Michael Porter Meets the "Strategy By Press Release" Crowd

Has Health Industry Group Purchasing Assn. president Curtis Rooney heard of Michael Porter or his "five forces" scheme for assessing an industry's competitive structure?  Doubtful. Notice off to the left there, a force titled "Bargaining Power of Suppliers?" (Click on the graphic for a better view.)  Apparently in Rooney's health care, that force only works in one direction. Instead of seeing Medtronic's canceling of several GPO contracts as a predictable attempt to shift some bargaining power back to device manufacturers, Rooney calls it “nothing short of an attack on America’s hospitals.” Yeah, that'll help. Funny, I can't find 'the power of the pulpit" anywhere on Porter's chart.  Those who can compete, do.  Those who can't, issue whiny, self-serving proclamations.

Don't Base Your Competitive Position On What Your Rivals Can Buy

 I see many hospitals building their competitive position around 'things' - bricks and mortar, shiny procedural technologies, robotics.  Why might this be a really bad idea? Because as competitive positions go, those based on so-called gadgets and gizmos go 'poof' the minute a deep-pocketed competitor writes a big check.  Hospital 'A' may have had it first, but, worst case, they've now spent their time and money educating the marketplace on their new competitor's behalf.  "You have a robot?  Hey, so do we!"  Back to the status quo ante , thank you very much.  'Things' are just means to an end, inputs to desired outputs.  Achieve those ends, produce those outputs better and cheaper than anybody else and you've really got something on which to build. Enduring competitive advantages are based on unique capabilities that cannot be purchased but must be developed through intense processes of learning and listening, innovating a...