Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label Reform

The ACA's Effect On Entrepreneurs Will Be...?

An article in yesterday's Wall Street Journal asked "Will Health-Care Law Beget Entrepreneurs?" Will the availability of reasonably-priced insurance through public marketplaces or "exchanges" cause entrepreneurs to strike out on their own, leaving behind the comfort of big company benefits? It's a good question, albeit one with no clear-cut answer at the moment. It all depends, I guess, on one's definition of "high-functioning exchanges" and "reasonable prices." Still, it's a question to which large companies ought to be paying close attention. How many people work at jobs simply for the health insurance, jobs they'd leave in a heartbeat to follow their passion if insurance wasn't an obstacle? I don't know for sure, but I'd bet the answer is somewhere between "more than a few" and "a whole heckavu lot." And those leaving are likely to be those the company wishes would stay - the innovat...

An Industry Bankrupting Its Own Customers Cannot Thrive

Wonder why you haven't gotten a raise recently?  Does it seem your income goes less far than in years past?  Blame healthcare inflation.  Or, as one economist said recently, "...healthcare stole your raise."   Brian Klepper, PhD , blogging at KevinMD.com predicts that healthcare is in for a new organizational structure. At our first meeting years ago, Tom Emerick, Walmart’s then VP of Global Benefits, told me, “No industry can grow continuously at a multiple of general inflation. It will eventually become so expensive that purchasers will simply abandon it.” He said it casually, as though it was obvious and indisputable. Health care is playing out this way. From 1999 to 2011, health care premium inflation grew steadily at 4 times the general inflation rate. During that same period, the percentage of non-elderly Americans with employer-sponsored health coverage fell from 69.2 to 58.6 percent, a 15.3 percent erosion rate. Health care’s boosters lik...

Diabesity: What if our best practices are the wrong practices?

The Daily Beast :   "...what if we are coordinating the wrong kind of care? What if our best practices are the wrong practices? Our toxic industrial diet, our sedentary lifestyle, chronic stress, and environmental toxins cause diabesity and its attendant downstream ills (often mislabeled as something else, such as hypertension, cancer, heart disease, dementia). Drugs and surgery are feeble, ineffective, costly, and often harmful treatments for lifestyle-induced illness. They are misguided efforts at best, dangerous at worst. Mounting evidence proves that the solution to lifestyle- and diet-driven obesity-related illnesses won’t be found at the bottom of a prescription bottle; they will be found at the end of our fork." [...] "Health it seems happens outside the clinic, where people live, work, play and pray. We need to rethink how we treat chronic disease. It is not only better medical management, which often just barely if at all staves off complications and death,...
MedCity News: What happens to healthcare reform if the individual mandate is overturned? Try this: things continue spiraling downward until 2020, when a Republican President signs national health insurance into law.

The Health Problems Of Rural America

From the StarTribune, citing research from UnitedHealth Group: "Residents of rural areas in Minnesota and across the nation are more likely to have chronic diseases and face hurdles to getting quality care, according to a UnitedHealth Group report that calls for new approaches to rural care." Compared to urban centers, rural America's problems include: A disproportionate share of people with chronic health conditions. An average travel distance of 60 miles to see a specialist. More patients with diabetes and high blood pressure. More caregivers naming teen pregnancy and drug abuse as top concerns. Solutions are multi-faceted and include: Expanding the nation's broadband network and handling more illnesses over the internet. Allowing broader roles for NPs and PAs to deal with a shortage of rural doctors. Addressing the reimbursement issues making rural practice less lucrative than urban settings. Says the study: "About 50 million Americans live in rur...
Singapore's health system places (great) emphasis on personal responsibility and economic incentives. "(And) what is most impressive about Singapore’s health care system is that the country spends about one-fifth as much per person on health care compared to the U.S., yet has better health outcomes." Personal responsibility? Economic incentives?  Do those terms still have a place in today's America?

Alternative Approaches To Leveling Our Cathedrals

From Dr. Westby Fisher via MedCity News: "Hospitals expand for future patients… who may not be able to afford care." "It doesn’t take many Betz cells to know what will happen when employers who presently pay $8,000-$9,000 per employee for health care benefits suddenly get the opportunity to pay a $2,000-per-employee “fine.” Do the math: for an employer with 3,000 employees, they pay about $65.5 million for the health care benefits they’re currently providing compared to a $6 million dollar “fine.” Seems like a nearly 10-fold savings to me! Now THAT, ladies and gentlemen, is one heck of a beneficial fine!" I can hear the Board chair now: "You mean that $200 million bed tower, justified on the thinnest of research about consumers preferring private rooms, might actually open to...NO demand?"

A Flash For the Policy Wonks Pushing ACOs

The Health Care Blog: Why ACOs Won't Work. "Here’s a flash for the policy wonks pushing ACOs: They only work if the provider gets paid less for the same patient population. Why would they be dumb enough to voluntarily accept that outcome? "Oh, there will be some providers—particularly hospital administrators—who can’t wait to build an ACO but probably more because they want another excuse to corner the primary care docs as a marketing channel for their growing system. But spend millions to develop an ACO so they can get less money? Only in the policy wonk netherland does that compute." ACOs or not, we're heading for an era where declining reimbursement meets increasing demand, where value and productivity are the keys to survival.

A Reform-Based Innovation Portfolio

Sg2: Optimizing Innovation in the Reform Era . "Health care systems may choose to manage innovation projects "right," when they would do better to manage the right innovation projects. While many organizations have processes for the former option, managing projects on time and in budget, true optimization of an innovation competency requires beefing up the latter option. This means maintaining an innovation portfolio, engaging in a dynamic process of evaluation, choice and project prioritization based on risk constraints, market trends and value derivation." (Graphic: Sg2)

Is Healthcare A Drag?

Yes, says McKinsey in this article on reducing the drag on the American Economy.  Fixing healthcare is first on the agenda. GDP growth is not going to happen "...until we free ourselves from four anchors that have acted as a drag on growth in this country for many years now: lagging productivity in healthcare, education, energy and infrastructure, and government services." [...] " In 2008, the United States spent $2.3 trillion on healthcare—that’s more than we spent on food, and more than China spent on everything. Adjusted for population, we spend $650 billion more on healthcare than any other developed country, yet our outcomes are no better. Much of this $650 billion in excess costs is driven by characteristics of our system that have proven difficult to change, including unusually high costs for outpatient programs, local market oligopolies, a failure to apply known best practices, price-insensitive patients who don’t see the cost of their healthcare and con...

Same Page? Not Even the Same Library!

From Quintiles: New research indicates that managed care executives, physicians and patients are not on the same page on a wide range of issues: "A question about personalized medicine found that 88 percent of biophama executives and 84 percent of managed care respondents felt these new products will be effective. But 75 percent of patient respondents answered “no” when asked if they had heard of personalized medicine. Respondents also could not agree on what constitutes “value” in healthcare. About 38 percent of pharma executives said any definition of value must include both cost and outcomes, while just 2 percent of patients felt that way" (Thanks to MedCity News for the heads-up.)

Will Employers Eliminate Health Coverage In 2014?

'Yes' says the smart money.   From AIS's Health Reform Week ; "Health insurance reform mandates already in effect are having a major cost impact on midsized employers across the U.S., according to a new actuarial modeling analysis by Lockton Benefit Group. On average, employers with 2,000 to 10,000 employees tacked another 2.5% onto their health insurance costs since mandates went into effect last September — primarily due to reform requirements extending dependent coverage to age 26 and eliminating lifetime and raising annual coverage limits, the firm says. Moreover, costs related to these mandates are just the tip of the iceberg — to the point where many employers could consider termination of their plans in 2014." [...] "Employers deciding to eliminate health plan coverage in 2014 will save an average of about 44% off their current health care spending, according to Lockton’s actuarial modeling. Thus, an employer spending $10 million today would spend...

The Math Of Healthcare Value

"ACOs are about improving health outcomes. 1990s style managed care was about reducing utilization." I ran across that statement yesterday, exactly where I can't remember. I think the author is right about the different emphases but wrong to imply the terms 'outcomes' and 'utilization' could be mutually exclusive.  Doing so misses the point - which is, then and now, all about VALUE. Let's define Value as:  [What we GET / What we PAY]. What do we GET from health care?  Outcomes. Results. Better health.  Longer lives.  Pain relief. What do we PAY?  In total, it's [ how many x how much ], or [utilization multiplied by unit costs]. So, Value = [What we get / What we pay]. Or, Value = [Outcomes / (utilization x unit costs)] Maximizing value - getting more and/or paying less - requires focusing on all of the equation's elements - outcomes, utilization and unit costs.   Yes, the 1995 response to Hillarycare might have been utiliz...

When Capital Markets Talk, Smart Leaders Pay Attention

Michael Sachs, Sg2 Chairman, on what the capital markets are saying to and about health care : "The (capital) markets are responding to a myriad of issues facing health care organizations—declines in utilization, the full impact of health reform and general acceptance that the cost of health care is sapping America of needed resources to fund job growth. The capital markets are saying that the industry’s current pace of response to these issues is inadequate, and this will bring about massive change in health care. "I just met with a very impressive group of health care CEOs who explained their strategies for transforming their organizations for the new era. But I came away from the meeting feeling as though I had heard the same words 15 years ago during the managed care era. There were major discussions about the need to invest in information systems, to the tune of $200 million in some cases. The CEOs showed lots of organizational charts describing physician integration ...

States Face Retirement's Health Costs

Baby boomers are retiring and they're living longer than decades-old projections said they would.  For some states, retiree health costs are growing 20 percent per year.   Can the health care industry survive by bankrupting its own customers?    Let's think about that for a moment.  Ummm, no. Because that's what's happening, slowly but surely.  Is the problem really one of demographics?  Really ?  Or are boomers' health care needs being poorly served by a rapacious, ruinously expensive health care megalopoly?  One day, mayors and governors will awaken to the fact that their biggest obstacle to cost control may not be public employee unions but health care's edifice-driven bureaucratic narcissism, fueled by budgets seemingly without limits. I know that's harsh and pardon the rant, but I don't see ACOs and their ilk solving the problem unless/until they become vehicles for fundamental cultural change and not the latest lawyer-devised means ...

Two Views Of the Future Of Employer-Sponsored Health Coverage

RE: the future of health insurance, Booz&Co calls forecasts of the demise of employer-sponsored coverage "greatly exaggerated." I hope they're right; I fear they're not.  Believing that large employers will continue offering coverage - at increasingly ruinous rates - out of a "sense of moral responsibility" is pure fantasy.   They saw no moral obligation when the issue was off-shoring jobs and they won't in this case either.  Nor, with slow-growth economic conditions projected to last as far as the gimlet eye can see, do they believe  themselves in much of a battle to "attract and retain talent."   Worse, they're herd-followers.  The more organizations dumping health insurance, the more we'll see jumping on the "we're doing it to stay competitive" bandwagon.  And so much for that. Small employers probably do have a larger sense of obligation, God bless 'em.  Their issue is health coverage's sheer unaffor...

Blue Cross Plans Improve Access With CRNPs

Extending some kind of insurance to forty million people when/if Obamacare takes hold presents health care with an opportunity AND a big problem.  The opportunity: new customers and increased demand.  The problem: we're thousands of physicians short of having adequate capacity to care for all those new customers. Already we're hearing calls for massive increases in Federal funding for the training pipeline - medical schools, residencies, etc.  Some increase is probably a good idea.  After all, what's the use of having a ticket to the big game if it doesn't buy you a seat in the stadium? But I doubt the pipeline can ramp up quickly enough, even with increased funding.  That leads to the search for alternatives.  There are, after all, many ways to build caregiver capacity besides simply producing more physicians. We might start by redoubling efforts to increase the efficiency of practicing physicians - less paperwork, fewer hassles, better systems and ...

PHOs As Transitional Models For ACOs

Still operating that PHO - Physician-Hospital Organization?  It may be a relic of 1990's-style managed care but I'll bet you learned many hard-won lessons along the way.  Don't give up now. Instead, use it as a stepping stone to a successful Accountable Care Organization (ACO.)  Improve your risk-sharing models, add healthy doses of transparency and physician leadership, and you just might have something there. While I'm at it, I spent yesterday in Chicago's western suburbs with a full day of meetings and networking. On one entrepreneurial project specifically, the discussion pointed out that my thinking on possibilities and potentials was WAY too constrained, by a factor of 10. Funny. I usually have the opposite problem, but in this case I'm thrilled to think millions, not tens of thousands. Thanks to all who helped with ideas and alternatives. And the day concluded wonderfully in a meeting with a hospital that truly understands what "competing on a...