Skip to main content

Dr. G's Fundamental Rules Of Budgeting

"Our annual battle with mental constipation" is how I used to refer to our interminable budget preparation sessions. For years I struggled, unsuccessfully, to find the right "laxative." Then one particularly grim season Dr. G., our new VP - Medical Affairs/CMO joined the team.

Dr. G was a newly-retired general surgeon and someone I'd always found more than a little intimidating. He was impatient, opinionated and occasionally blunt to point of rudeness...and absolutely the surgeon you'd want operating on yourself or a loved one.

The sessions dragged on, the days turning into weeks as we pursued those elusive EBITDA points. Though a careful observer, Dr. G said very little. Yet I noticed him taking lots of notes, sometimes with wry, little smile. As the sessions drew to a close I asked for his observations on the process.

In response, he handed me his notes, now typed and titled "The Fundamental Laws Of Budgeting." Believe it or not, they're actual comments and lines of argument, recorded as, one after another, beleaguered department directors defended their budget drafts before a cranky committee of executives and budget trolls.

How stupid did we sound? I'll leave that to you, dear reader, as I offer Dr. G's 23 laws:
  1. If we only have one of something and it breaks we're in real trouble; so we need at least two of everything.
  2. The actual number of FTEs budgeted is never the same as the number actually used.
  3. All equipment, no matter when purchased, is old, outmoded and in need of constant, expensive repair.
  4. Decreased turn-around time can be used to justify most any request.
  5. The relationship between revenue and expense, if any, can be emphasized or ignored at will.
  6. New technology is (a) always unreasonably demanded by physicians, and (b) can't be profitable until physicians are "educated" to use it.
  7. Not enough marketing is partly to blame for everything.
  8. Every choice has a domino effect and I am a domino.
  9. Management will grow at its own rate regardless.
  10. People who are retired or deceased can't be counted as FTEs.
  11. If there is no solid rationale for making a decision, a majority vote will do.
  12. All budget objectives are basically unattainable; any target actually reached was the wrong target to begin with.
  13. The more an issue is examined and discussed, the fuzzier it becomes.
  14. One person can never do the job of one person. A part of another person is needed to work vacations, sick leaves, breaks and other paid time off. And so it follows that full time is always part time which leads to overtime which then requires, you guessed it, MORE FTEs.
  15. All comparisons with external benchmarks that are unfavorable to us are demonstrably invalid.
  16. One thing you can count on: nothing ever gets better.
  17. At any individual's convenience, an increase can be a decrease and a decrease can be an increase.
  18. The statistic never accurately reflects the fact.
  19. You've got to know when to hold 'em and know when to fold 'em.
  20. The budget process is essentially a contest between squeaky wheels and knot holes.
  21. If appeals to reason don't work, mention your competition.
  22. Everyone's ox is gored.
  23. When all is said and done, there's only so much money.
Not a pretty picture, eh? The good news is that Dr. G's observations caused sufficient embarrassment that the next year's cycle got a whole lot better. Funny how that works.


smm said…
I remember these rules with great fondness (and great accuracy).

Popular posts from this blog

Being Disrupted Ain't Fun. Deal With It.

Articles about disrupting healthcare, particularly those analogizing, say, Tesla's example with healthcare's current state, are frequently met with a chorus of (paraphrasing here) "Irrelevant! Cars are easy, healthcare is hard." You know, patients and doctors as examples of "information asymmetry" and all that. Well, let me ask you this: assuming you drive a car with a traditional internal combustion engine, how much do you know about the metallurgy in your car's engine block? I'll bet the answer is: virtually nothing. In fact it's probably less than you know about your own body's GI tract. Yet somehow, every day, us (allegedly) ignorant people buy and drive cars without help from a cadre of experts. Most of us do so and live happily ever after (at least until the warranty expires. Warranties...another thing healthcare could learn from Tesla.) Now, us free range dummies - impatient with information asymmetry - are storming healthcar…

Becoming Consumer Friendly In Five Easy Steps...Or Not

An article at offers hospitals 5 steps to becoming more consumer friendly.

If you still think there's a secret sauce to your hospital becoming more "consumer friendly," these 5 steps are as good a place to start as any.  Unfortunately, it's a little like that old Steve Martin comedy bit where he says he'll teach you how to be rich. The first step is to go find a million dollars.

Step 1 from the article is realizing that "...a Medicare beneficiary with chronic conditions is different from a young mom who brings her kids in for an annual check-up." This is market segmentation for beginners, and, yes, one size decidedly does not fit all. I'm sure your marketing team's been saying this for a while.

Steps 2-5: have a strategy, metrics, a champion and resources. OK. Hard to argue with any of those.

But those things, alone or together, won't overcome culture. They're important components to be sure, but insufficient without a …

The Answer For Lower Healthcare Costs Is...

...Customer Service.

From the New York Times: Seattle's Iora Primary Care is a new model of primary care, seeking national scale and venture capital funding.  Though the ambition may be outsize, the concepts are not new. Daily team huddles. Health coaches. Taking satisfaction surveys seriously and mining results for actionable insights. Employer and payer partnerships. Pay-for-performance not volumes. Loose-tight operations (wellness options are "loose" - i.e. varying from site to
site, while EHR alignment is "tight" and non-negotiable.)

According to the article:
"...small change(s) can make a big difference in a patient’s health — what good is the perfect drug if the patient can’t swallow it? — but the extra-mile work it took to get there can be a challenge for the typical primary care practice in the United States. Harried by busy schedules and paid on a piecework model, many doctors rush from visit to visit, avoid phone calls and emails that …