Skip to main content

Where's The Value?

We're coming up on an anniversary of sorts, an anniversary of the day I attended a charrette and nearly caused a riot.

See, I was representing my then-employer at a two-day planning retreat (also called a charrette) on the subject of building a statewide health information network, known generically as a CHIN or a RHIO. More than 100 leaders had gathered from hospitals, physician groups, payers, the ranks of tech and IT gurus and various levels of government, all with the purpose of moving the discussions from concept to something implementable.

As the festivities drew to a close, despite the group's best efforts, no compelling value proposition existed for the network. No statement of clear benefit emerged.  There was certainly no hint of how life could be improved for the end user (i.e. the patient.)  Even worse, the group's only funding plan consisted of the relatively few hospitals in the room each writing a big check.

Aspirations were running high.  Specifics were in desperately short supply.

At which point the local Blue Cross rep looked over at me and said "You know, if you hospitals would fund this system, we at Blue Cross could pay you sooner."

"You could pay us sooner NOW if you wanted to," I responded. "You just choose not to because you like money in YOUR bank account better than you like it in ours. A CHIN won't change that!"

Oops. If looks could kill I'd be writing this from whatever zip code contains Forest Lawn.  After some reflection, I could have been more judicious in my word choice, could have asked for more specifics on just how building a private-label version of the internet would accelerate hospital cash flow.  Woulda, coulda, shoulda.  I didn't.

But years later, several things are still clear as crystal:
  1. Health care's value propositions are frequently anything but.
  2. When you spend 2 days of 100 people's time trying to create a value proposition and FAIL, it's either bad facilitation or, maybe, there isn't any value to be created.  (And I might add that on this particular day the facilitators (not me) were pretty good.)
  3. Given half a chance and lots of someone else's money, groups will do their best to reinvent the wheel, or, in this case, the internet.
  4. Large doses of hospital funding won't change #1 or #2 and will only worsen #3.
  5. Suspicion is the correct stance when a payer wants a hospital to spend lots of money so they, the payer, can do their job promptly and correctly.
So say it proudly;

Charrettes are cool!
CHINs are neat!
But when value leads,
Your day is complete!

Thanks for reading.  Join the conversation.  Leave a comment.  Spark an argument.  Send me a message (  And about Blue Cross?  I'm still right.


Popular posts from this blog

Becoming Consumer Friendly In Five Easy Steps...Or Not

An article at offers hospitals 5 steps to becoming more consumer friendly.

If you still think there's a secret sauce to your hospital becoming more "consumer friendly," these 5 steps are as good a place to start as any.  Unfortunately, it's a little like that old Steve Martin comedy bit where he says he'll teach you how to be rich. The first step is to go find a million dollars.

Step 1 from the article is realizing that "...a Medicare beneficiary with chronic conditions is different from a young mom who brings her kids in for an annual check-up." This is market segmentation for beginners, and, yes, one size decidedly does not fit all. I'm sure your marketing team's been saying this for a while.

Steps 2-5: have a strategy, metrics, a champion and resources. OK. Hard to argue with any of those.

But those things, alone or together, won't overcome culture. They're important components to be sure, but insufficient without a …

My Take On Anthem-Cigna, Big Dumb Companies and the Executives Who Run Them

After last Friday's Appeals Court decision, Anthem's hostile takeover of, er, merger with Cigna has but a faint pulse. Good. Unplug the respirator. Cigna's figured it out but Anthem is like that late-late horror show where the corpse refuses to die. Meanwhile, 150 McKinsey consultants are on standby for post-merger "integration" support. I guess "no deal, no paycheck..." is powerfully motivating to keep the patient alive a while longer.

In court, Anthem argued that assembling a $54 billion behemoth is a necessary precondition to sparking all manner of wondrous innovations and delivering $2.4 billion in efficiencies. The basic argument appears to be "We need to double in size to grow a brain. And just imagine all those savings translating directly into lower premiums for employers and consumers." 

Stop. Read that paragraph again. Ignore the dubious "lower premiums" argument and focus on the deal's savings.

$2.4 billion saved from a p…

Another Day, Another App, Another Satisfied Customer

How might health care providers use technology to turn customers' mobile phones into information displays and ordering devices? A few years ago, the NY Times outlined how retailers are doing it...
"(Designer Norma) Kamali is at the forefront of a technological transformation coming to many of the nation’s retailers. They are determined to strengthen the link between their physical stores and the Web, and to use technology to make shopping easier for consumers and more lucrative for themselves.

Cisco Systems, the supplier of networking equipment and services for the Internet, is also a leader in the field. The company’s Mobile Concierge system is capable of connecting customers’ smartphones to retailers’ wireless networks — so a shopper could type “Cheez Whiz” into a cellphone, then pinpoint its location in the store." Ms. Kamali's boutique installed a technology called ScanLife, "allowing people to scan bar codes on merchandise and obtain details about the…